The Conundrum of Self-Doubt
"Doubt kills more dreams than failure ever will."
– Suzy Kassem
The Conundrum of Self-Doubt
Why is it that those who stand to gain the most from self-doubt often seem to possess the least, while those prone to it experience it so intensely that it becomes paralyzing?
This paradox holds profound implications for everything from personal relationships to societal discourse. Understanding its dynamics sheds light on why some people cling to unfounded conspiracy theories, while others remain trapped in toxic relationships despite knowing better.
The Purpose of Self-Doubt: A Double-Edged Sword
At its core, self-doubt serves a useful function. It encourages:
- Reflection – Making us pause and rethink assumptions.
- Humility – Allowing us to acknowledge our limitations.
- Perspective – Helping us consider alternative viewpoints.
In small, manageable doses, self-doubt fosters growth and prevents costly mistakes. However, when it is absent or exaggerated, it wreaks havoc on decision-making and self-trust.
Extreme Confidence vs. Paralyzing Self-Doubt
The Overconfident: When Certainty Becomes a Shield
Many conspiracy theorists and individuals with extreme beliefs exhibit an unshakable certainty. They reject overwhelming evidence, cling to baseless theories, and often view themselves as possessing “special insight.”
In these cases, self-doubt could be beneficial, prompting them to:
- Critically examine their sources
- Reflect on their biases
- Engage in open discussions
But for these individuals, doubt is an existential threat. It is far easier to double down on a comforting narrative than to allow cracks of uncertainty to form. This defensive mechanism shields them from emotional upheaval and cognitive dissonance.
The Self-Doubting: When Uncertainty Becomes Paralyzing
On the other end of the spectrum are those who are consumed by self-doubt, to the point where they:
- Second-guess every decision
- Question their self-worth
- Fear making mistakes
This level of self-doubt can be so overwhelming that it stifles personal growth and makes individuals vulnerable to manipulation.
In abusive relationships, self-doubt often prevents victims from leaving. They question their reality, feel undeserving of better treatment, and become trapped in cycles of confusion and guilt.
Research-based, personalized therapy.
At My LA Therapy, our warm and experienced therapists specialize in relationships, trauma, & codependency.
The Root Causes of Self-Doubt Imbalance
The roots of self-doubt imbalance often lie in early conditioning. For those who reject self-doubt entirely, there is usually a history of receiving validation for extreme certainty or growing up in an environment that rewards unwavering conviction over humility and reflection.
From an early age, these individuals may have been taught that being confident and decisive, no matter the situation, was the path to success. As a result, they become comfortable rejecting any form of self-doubt, seeing it as a weakness rather than a tool for growth.
On the other side, those struggling with excessive self-doubt often have a history marked by lack of validation or constant criticism. Environments that invalidate their feelings, question their worth, or leave them second-guessing their decisions can create a foundation of low self-trust.
For these individuals, self-doubt becomes habitual, often reinforced by the voices of others—or even their own internalized beliefs—that they’re not good enough or capable of making sound judgments.
How to Cultivate a Healthy Balance Between Self-Doubt and Self-Trust
For Those Who Resist Self-Doubt
The key is to embrace intellectual humility—the ability to admit when you don’t know everything. To cultivate this:
- Engage with diverse perspectives
- Actively seek constructive feedback
- Practice sitting with discomfort rather than rejecting it
Learning to say “I don’t know” or “I could be wrong” is not weakness—it is a sign of strength.
For Those Who Are Consumed by Self-Doubt
The key is to strengthen self-trust. This can be done by:
- Recognizing that self-doubt is often rooted in fear, not fact
- Challenging negative self-talk (e.g., “I’m not good enough,” “I always fail”)
- Building small wins to reinforce confidence
By learning to trust their intuition and take risks, those who struggle with self-doubt can regain a sense of agency.
How Narcissists Exploit Self-Doubt
Manipulative individuals, especially narcissists, use self-doubt as a weapon to control others. By amplifying uncertainty, they create a dependency loop where their victim seeks reassurance—only to receive further invalidation.
Common tactics include:
- Gaslighting – Making the victim question their own reality
- Withholding validation – Keeping their approval just out of reach
- Reinforcing self-doubt – Leading the victim to feel incapable of independent thought
This manipulation thrives on confirmation bias—a tendency to seek out information that aligns with existing beliefs. Over time, victims internalize the narcissist’s devaluation, further eroding self-trust.
The Key to Growth: Finding the Balance
Finding Balance Across Time
Just as too much self-doubt can make someone vulnerable to manipulation, unchecked self-trust can lead to arrogance and blind certainty. The key lies in cultivating a balance between the two. This balance allows us to reflect on our thoughts and feelings without becoming paralyzed by indecision or overwhelmed by external influence.
A healthy dose of self-doubt invites curiosity and growth, encouraging us to examine our assumptions and remain open to learning from others. But this must be anchored in self-trust—the belief in our own capacity to make sound judgments, even when those judgments contradict external opinions. When we cultivate both self-doubt and self-trust in proportion, we remain grounded, resilient to manipulation, and open to personal growth.
This balance prevents the extremes of excessive self-doubt or unchecked certainty. It keeps us anchored in inner stability while still allowing for flexibility, adaptation, and self-awareness. Doubt should not lead to despair, just as trust should not lead to stubborn inflexibility. The goal is to develop an internal compass that allows us to navigate life with confidence while staying open to growth, self-correction, and change.
We find you the perfect therapist.
We deep dive into your unique needs to find you a therapist who matches your schedule, style, & budget.
Final Thoughts: Reclaiming Your Confidence
Self-doubt, when properly balanced, is not a flaw to be eradicated but a guidepost for personal growth. It’s not about silencing doubt altogether—it’s about learning when to listen to it and when to let it go. Just as too little self-doubt can lead to destructive certainty, too much can trap us in a cycle of fear and hesitation. The goal isn’t perfection or absolute certainty, but rather the ability to move through life with self-awareness, adaptability, and confidence.
The real challenge is not to eliminate doubt, but to use it wisely—to allow it to inform our decisions without controlling them. When we learn to balance self-trust with self-reflection, we free ourselves from the limitations of both unchecked arrogance and crippling uncertainty. In this balance, we find the space to grow, to question, and to truly understand ourselves.
Your Journey to Healing Starts Here
Your Next Step
Transformation doesn’t happen overnight, but you don’t have to walk this path alone.
At My LA Therapy, we specialize in understanding your unique challenges and creating a customized roadmap to healing with a person-centered approach.
Ready to uncover the real path to self-transformation?
Let us guide you. Schedule a consultation.
Stay curious, stay compassionate, and know that your journey is uniquely yours.
And in that uniqueness lies your power.
In the meantime, stay true, brave, and kind,
– Brooke
Share this post
Brooke Sprowl is an industry-leading expert and author in psychology, spirituality, and self-transformation. Her insights have featured in dozens of media outlets such as Huffington Post, Business Insider, Cosmopolitan Magazine, the Los Angeles Times, Spectrum One News, Mind Body Green, YourTango, and many more. As the founder and CEO of My LA Therapy, she leads a team of 15 dedicated therapists and wellness professionals. Brooke has been a featured speaker at prominent universities and venues such as UCLA School of Public Affairs, USC, Loyola Marymount University, the Mark Taper Auditorium, and Highways Performance Gallery, to name a few. With a Master’s degree in Clinical Social Welfare with a Mental Health Specialization from UCLA, a Bachelor’s degree in Neuroscience from USC, and certifications in peak performance and flow science from the Flow Research Collective, Brooke has helped hundreds of prominent leaders and CEO’s overcome anxiety, relationship difficulties, and trauma and reclaim a sense of purpose, vitality, and spiritual connection. With 15 years of experience in personal development and self-transformation as a therapist and coach, she has pioneered dozens of original concepts and frameworks to guide people in overcoming mental health challenges and awakening spiritually. Brooke is the host of the podcast, Waking Up with Brooke Sprowl. She is passionate about writing, neuroscience, philosophy, integrity, poetry, spirituality, creativity, effective altruism, personal and collective healing, and curating luxury, transformational retreat experiences for high-achievers seeking spiritual connection.
